What’s Fair and What’s Fear?
The topic of transgender athletes in sports is one of those things that seems to spark endless debate. Some folks worry it’s unfair—assuming trans women have advantages over cisgender women. Others argue that sports should be for everyone, no matter who they are. What’s frustrating, though, is how often these conversations get sidetracked by myths and misunderstandings.
At the heart of it, this isn’t just a “debate.” It’s about real people—athletes who want to compete, feel included, and just play the sports they love. So, let’s talk about what’s actually true and where this conversation should go.
Do Trans Women Have an Advantage?
This is probably the number one flawed argument you’ll hear—trans women have a physical edge in sports. At first glance, it seems like a simple idea. But the reality is a lot more complicated (as most things are).
Here’s the thing—many transgender women undergo hormone therapy, which profoundly changes their bodies. It’s not just a tweak—it’s a transformation. Research, like a 2020 study published in Sports Medicine, shows that within a year of hormone therapy, muscle mass and strength drop significantly. Hemoglobin levels (important for endurance) decrease too. This brings their physical abilities much closer to cisgender women. Sure, some differences might remain, but sports have always been about differences, haven’t they?
And then there’s this whole idea that trans athletes are “dominating” women’s sports. Spoiler— they’re not. Data from the Center for American Progress shows that trans athletes make up less than 1% of competitors. Let that sink in for a second. And there’s no evidence that they’re disproportionately winning. So where’s this idea coming from? Fear, maybe?
Honestly, when you think about it, every athlete brings something unique to the table. Michael Phelps? His wingspan and physiology were practically built for swimming. Usain Bolt? His stride is unreal. Even Serena Williams’s raw power sets her apart from the majority of her female competitors. We celebrate these differences, don’t we? So why is it suddenly a problem when it comes to trans athletes?
What’s Really Unfair in Sports?
Here’s something that doesn’t get talked about enough— if fairness in sports is the concern, why are we ignoring the significant barriers that hold athletes back?
Take money, for example. Athletes from wealthier families have access to better coaches, equipment, and training facilities, from elementary school onward. Meanwhile, kids from low-income households often struggle just to get started. A 2020 study in the Journal of Sport and Social Issues found that only 15% of elite athletes come from low-income families, even though those families make up over 40% of the population. That’s a massive disparity, but how often do we hear about it?
And race plays a role too. Many sports—especially ones like swimming or gymnastics—are out of reach for marginalized communities because of systemic barriers. If we really want to make sports fair, these are the issues we should be tackling.
The Real Cost of Exclusion
Let’s get personal for a minute. Imagine being a high school athlete who’s worked hard, trained for years, and just loves competing. Now imagine walking onto the track and hearing people boo, just because of who you are. That’s exactly what Andraya Yearwood, a transgender runner, has faced. And she’s not alone. The Human Rights Campaign reports a rise in violence against transgender people, fueled in part by debates like this one. It’s heartbreaking.
It’s not just about public hostility either. The mental health toll is enormous. For many transgender athletes, sports are more than just a game—they’re a lifeline. They provide a sense of community, belonging, and confidence. But when exclusionary policies shut them out, that’s taken away. Studies have shown that trans individuals already face higher rates of anxiety and depression. Do you want to be an active participant in making these traumatic experiences even worse?
So, Where Do We Go From Here?
If we want to make sports fair and welcoming, the solution isn’t exclusion—it’s understanding. Here’s what we need to focus on.
First, let’s stick to the facts. The idea that trans athletes have an overwhelming advantage just doesn’t hold up. The science is clear, and there are already policies in place, like those from the IOC and NCAA, to ensure fairness.
Second, we need to remember what sports are really about. Sure, competition is part of it, but sports are also about teamwork, resilience, and community. Including transgender athletes doesn’t take anything away from that. In fact, it makes sports richer, more inclusive, and more meaningful.
Finally, let’s listen. Trans athletes have stories that deserve to be heard. When we take the time to understand their experiences, it’s a lot easier to see through the noise and focus on what really matters.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, this isn’t just a policy debate—it’s about discrimination. It’s about exclusion. It’s about people. Transgender athletes aren’t asking for special treatment. They’re just asking for the chance to play, to compete, to belong. Isn’t that what sports are all about? By choosing inclusion, we’re not just supporting the trans community—we’re upholding the values that make sports great—fairness, respect, and unity.
References
Harper, J. (2020). Effects of Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy on Exercise Performance in Transgender Athletes. Sports Medicine.
Storr, R., & Bekker, S. (2024). Gender Inclusive Sport— What’s in it for (All) Women? Research Handbook on Gender and Diversity in Sport.
Athlete Ally & Women’s Sports Foundation (2021). Transgender Inclusion in Sports— A Report.
Human Rights Campaign (2023). Annual Report on Anti-Trans Violence.
Comments